TrueJoshNight Truly Dreadful Film

Hadrina The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Allison Davies The film never slows down or bores, plunging from one harrowing sequence to the next.

Geraldine The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

MARIO GAUCI I recall watching the UPA cartoons featuring "The Nearsighted Mister Magoo" – as his full credit appears here – on Italian TV as a kid; for the record, the "Leslie Halliwell Film Guide" rates his 1952 'vehicle' BAREFACED FLATFOOT a highly respectable ***! Recently, too, I did catch his inevitable 1962 rendition – via a half-hour special – of "A Christmas Carol"; however, I did not bother with the live-action Leslie Nielsen incarnation (or, should I say, abomination) when it emerged in the late 1990s. Anyway, this delightful effort emerged the winner of the Best Animated Short Oscar: typically voiced by Jim Backus, Magoo goes out to experience a 3-D movie but he invariably takes a detour and winds up a passenger on a plane; he takes the flight to be the realism of the movie and, when the man next to him disappears but leaves his bag behind (he proves to be a spy being chased by cops), Magoo goes to look for him all over the place – literally, even walking on the wings of the plane, through clouds (which he mistakes for the smoking area of the theatre!) and even sliding across the cockpit windscreen to demand the flabbergasted pilots if they have seen the man in question! Incidentally, among the film's competitors at the Oscars were Tex Avery's CRAZY MIXED-UP PUP and the "Tom & Jerry" swashbuckler TOUCHE', PUSSYCAT!

MartinHafer This rant isn't new for me, but as this film earned the Oscar for Best Animated Short, I feel it wouldn't hurt to do it once again. In the 40s and much of the 50s, Hollywood was producing some of the greatest animated shorts in history. Amazing characters like Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, Tom & Jerry, Droopy and the like were coming into their own and the quality of the toons were amazing...simply amazing. However, starting in the very early 50s, some cynical cheapskates decided that cartoons were mostly watched by children and that children were stupid, so they wouldn't notice or care when cheap animation was substituted. Low frame-rates, lousy backgrounds and poor animation quality was in and one of the worst perpetrators of this catastrophe (Columbia Pictures) was actually rewarded for making wretched and cheap cartoons. Believe it or not, cartoons like Gerald McBoing-Boing and Mr. Magoo were getting Oscars while great products like those of respected studios were being overlooked. Had crack been popular then, I might be able to explain the Academy's decisions--but I can't.This is one of many Mr. Magoo cartoons. And while some hate them for their political correctness, I cringed at WHEN MAGOO FLEW's horrid animation--third-rate throughout and an offense against humanity. The story was dumb but the animation made my skin crawl. And to think it got an Oscar!!!!

Robert Reynolds This short won the Oscar and probably deserved to. It's an excellent effort and one of the shining moments of the Mister Magoo series of theaterically released shorts. It is hilarious and quite mad and chaotic, even for a Magoo cartoon. Most recommended.

kcox5342 Magoo goes off to the movies, but makes a wrong turn and ends up on a plane, in the midst of a cops and robbers plot he inadvertently foils. This one is above the average Mr. Magoo cartoon, because it has several secondary characters with good lines. My favorite is when the detective says to the stewardess, "I'm looking for a man", and she shoots back with a deadpan, "Me too." The cops and robbers plot is all done in stylized, almost noir fashion. Even the bumbling Magoo bits are funnier than usual, as when he appears in the window of the cockpit. And that end line about "Have you got any cartoons with that short nearsighted fellow?" exhibit a self-referential tongue in cheek that sets this one above your average Magoo.