Platicsco
Good story, Not enough for a whole film
Pacionsbo
Absolutely Fantastic
Raymond Sierra
The film may be flawed, but its message is not.
turetskyneil
Based on excellent writer Ian McEwan novel, this film managed to balance very nicely two themes, a troubled marriage and exploration of religious freedom in life and death health decisions. Issues of sexuality dying in middle age couples, overwork's effects on intimacy quietly and maturely looked at. No easy answers given. What to decide when a religious family refuses to permit a medically needed blood transfusion for religious reasons. A really remarkable acting tour de force by Emma Thompson, Stanley Tucci very good as beloved but sexually frustrated spouse, and very amusing spot on character acting by the "clark". Interesting peeks into England's legal system, and some very good cinematography of English countryside.. Slightly flawed by some melodramatic and poorly explained plot turns, the movie is still a must see, very smart and entertaining.
Ayal Oren
This is a very deep and thought provoking movie, relying on a supurb cast performance with Emma Thompson heading the list.
Be careful reading the synopsis as it contains a few significant errors, might be based on the novel. I can't explain the errors without adding spoilers, and I don't do these. The basic point of this movie is a confrontation between a woman striving to be as rational as possible, being a judge, and facing the limitations of pure rationalism when she has to rule on a question of faith. While faith also struggles to come out from this confrontation unscathed, as manifest by the young boy who has to live with the ruling of the judge. Very cleverly the story doesn't end with the judges ruling but with both sides of the debate having to live with the consequences of the ruling.
The story is told with very English reserve that suits it very well. That's all one needs to know, before seeing it. If you get the chance do see it.
mandikaplan
Everything about this movie is extraordinary and engaging. Powerful direction, dialogue, acting and cinematography.
