Artivels Undescribable Perfection

Protraph Lack of good storyline.

Baseshment I like movies that are aware of what they are selling... without [any] greater aspirations than to make people laugh and that's it.

AnhartLinkin This story has more twists and turns than a second-rate soap opera.

kijii Mickey Rooney received an Oscar nomination for Best Actor in a Supporting Role in this movie which presents a small group of American soldiers in Italy in 1944. Three types of soldiers are presented here, based on their reactions to their first encounter with the German enemy while in Italy. Rooney is the energetic and a happy go-with-the-punches soldier. Wendell Corey is a fairly well balanced soldier but is unable to kill the enemy when he is faced with the possibility. Don Taylor is a superman in battle situations but has trouble when faced with normal human spiritual matters, no doubt stunted by his upbringing. Nicole Maurey is a local Italian prostitute, forced to sell herself for survival.

lchadbou-326-26592 I saw this on Mickey Rooney's 93rd (!) birthday. It's in some ways a typical mid 50s U.S. product: One of those titles popular at the time (The Bad And The Beautiful, The Proud And The Profane, etc.), a theme song (co-written by Rooney) played during the opening and end credits, and one of the dubious then trendy widescreen spinoffs, SuperScope (It is hard to judge how well it was used here as the only watcheable copy I was able to find is in the standard TV ratio.) The story of American foot soldiers in Italy in 1944 concentrates on three characters who have a certain amount of psychological depth in the (Oscar nominated) writing. Wendell Corey stars as a cynical, well off guy who's afraid to shoot but not surprisingly gets the courage in the well done climax to fire back and even destroy a German tank. Don Taylor's role is the most complex, as the sergeant Preacher, a hard taskmaster, sexually repressed, and unable to accept when he finally meets a woman that she has already been with others.But Rooney, nominated for a Supporting Actor Oscar, has the show stealing big scene, as a gambling obsessed little dynamo, when he plays with dice in a tent full of other soldiers and scrambles for his scattered bills after the lights go out. In the combat scenes that finally come, an hour into the picture, when they go on recon patrol in a forest, he gets killed trying to retrieve some of these winnings.(The rock formations later in this scene are a giveaway that the movie was shot not in Italy but in Southern California.) Rooney's acting throughout is hyper, wound up, almost as if he were on pep pills during the shooting.Director Lewis Foster, based on his credits, looks worthy of further study.

william-gruendler I hadn't seen this since childhood; the moving climax stuck in my mind long after the ballad sung over the credits faded from memory. The crap game is somewhat replicated a few years later in the memorable Mickey Rooney-starring episode of COMBAT!: "Silver Service". Mickey brings the same self-effacing, self-sacrificing ebullience to the role of Harry White as he does to Dooley in The BOLD AND THE BRAVE... Louis Morgan says, on his blog: ''Mickey Rooney is an actor who is commonly derided by modern viewers for his Rooney mannerisms, and tendency to overact his parts. I must personally I have no animosity toward Rooney. Firstly he showed in The Human Comedy he is capable of giving a moving performance, secondly I personally never had a problem with his Rooneyisms. This is not to say that I do not understand people who do hold this animosity, Rooney certainly is an actor that if he rubs you the wrong way he probably really rubs you the wrong way. He simply does not annoy me in that way, although it most certainly is true that his performances tend to be better when they are further away from a typical Rooney performance than closer.''Highest recommendation!

bux I recently viewed this movie after not seeing it in several decades. It had always stuck out in my memory as one of the best of the 1950s war movies.The writing was excellent, a great story of men in war, the brave, the bold, the fallen, the fallen women, and the pious men. The crux of the plot concerns a religious zealot that disdains alcohol, women and gambling, yet feels no empathy at blowing away the enemy. God and Country I guess. As the story progresses, he feels betrayed by his comrades.The problem I had, was that during the first half of the movie, the acting seemed stiff and all but Rooney seemed to be over-acting...to the point of parody. Then about half way thru, things pick up and so does the acting. I wonder, since Rooney is "un-credited" as one of the directors, perhaps he stepped in to pull this one out of the fire.The crap game is legendary, and the final action is quite good. The ballad sung over the opening credits and at the conclusion are an added bonus.While not quite as good as "Attack"(1956) or "The Steel Helmet"(1951) this is still fun 50s war stuff.