Solemplex To me, this movie is perfection.

GamerTab That was an excellent one.

BootDigest Such a frustrating disappointment

Dotbankey A lot of fun.

Sjhm Beautiful young woman falls in love with poor, but honest, young man. He witnesses a crime committed by associates of her father, and is murdered on the eve of the concert which would have made him a huge success. Heartbroken young woman is sent to New Zealand, where fate has a strange trick to play upon her. Another young man with the face of her murdered love.The story is not particularly original, but is materially lifted by the engaging performances of the two leads. This was Hrithik's debut, and as such it is a very assured performance. He is heart-meltingly sweet as both Rohit and Raj, and he does manage to convey the differences between them quite effectively (quite a difficult task as they are both "nice" young men).The songs are quite catchy, and whilst the dancing isn't as good as Hrithik's later films, I fully understand why this film made him a superstar. Theatrically, not especially challenging, but he manages to play the two roles as two different people.This is a sweet, lovely popcorn movie, buy it on DVD to enjoy...

arundathi I love this movie so much. I think I have seen it 6 times and every time is a new experience. First off, when reading the trivia I learned that Hrithik asked his father to choose someone new other than Shahrukh Khan. That was a smart move. Although I love SRK, he is famous already and sometimes it is boring to see the same faces over and over again. I'm glad Hrithik changed this father's mind. Second, this was a beautiful entrance in introduce two new stars. Hrithik did not over act like in Mujhse Dosti Karonge and he was quite entertaining in this movie. Amisha (surprise) did not overact that much either. She was smooth and didn't do her hyperventilating crying. She added substance into the movie so it would be quite entertaining and Hrithik can flex his muscles and vent his anger. She and her cousin (in the movie) were funny. The story line, cinematography, songs and directing were wonderful and appealing. Rakesh Roshan and (I think) Rajesh (with the songs) did amazing jobs, making the audience thirsty for the songs and newcomers Hrithik Roshan and Amisha Patel.

sweetrupturedlight I must say that i am a dedicated Bollywood supporter and only recently had the opportunity of seeing this movie for the second time, forming a definite opinion. what a load of nonsense! this is the typical bollywood movies, that makes you cringe everytime the actors say a word! I had heared so much about Amisha that i had envisioned this radient beauty, much to my disappointment. In fact, she is rather plain. Kirti Reddy looks better than her! Hrithik, the one and only good thing abou the movie, looks good, and acts even better! I found the soundtrack to be lacking something and the dance sequences PATHETIC!!! Farah Khan - capable of so much more! The sequence in the title track had me in fits of laughter! PATHETIC!!!So, is there anything else that was good about this movie? Not really. Hrithik...Hrithik...Hrithik. other than that - NO. where the hype came from, heaven knows. i thought this was distinctly average!

stjohns If you know how to suspend disbelief, you will enjoy this movie. It was my first Hindi movie and I saw it in India. It was GREAT!! I don't normally enjoy musicals, but this was an exception. The singing & dancing were terrific. The title song is a big hit in India. The movie didn't look much like the India I saw, but the cinematography was excellent, and the sound was Dolby Digital (Indians like their movies loud). I could follow the storyline even though I understand no Hindi. It helped that there was a smattering of english throughout the movie. I can't wait to see it again with subtitles. Apparently most Indian movies have the same plot, singing, and dancing, so if you have seen a lot of these movies, it may not excite you like it did me, but I thought it was a well made (slick comes to mind), well acted, and a well produced piece of "Bollywood". The producer introduced his son with this picture, and he has become the heartthrob of India. I'm not good at analyzing movies so I'll finish by just saying, I came out of the theater with a smile on my face, and a tune in my head. This movie was FUN!