BootDigest Such a frustrating disappointment

Pluskylang Great Film overall

Catangro After playing with our expectations, this turns out to be a very different sort of film.

Ariella Broughton It is neither dumb nor smart enough to be fun, and spends way too much time with its boring human characters.

ksf-2 Mixed emotions about this one. Some fun, upbeat stuff, and big names like Margaret Hamilton and Jack Haley, in starring roles, post Wizard. Gene Krupa. Some funny lines in this thing, specifically the diner scene. Clever jokes and banter. Kills some time, but you don't really have to pay attention to the plot. I think the point is to highlight the bands and performers. They also reprise "Life is Just a Bowl of Cherries", which shows up in various films from time to time, usually with a stripper or silly act. Didn't really dig the bit where a young girl seems to lip synch, while playing Joan as a youngster. didn't really work. "Liza" played on the organ also brought this to a crashing halt. should have left that out. The thin plot here is just all over the map, but it doesn't really matter. Directed by Felix Feist.

bkoganbing I have a feeling that over at RKO they heard that MGM was doing The Ziegfeld Follies and decided to do George White's Scandals. White who was an actor as well as producer appeared in his own shows and in adaptions over at 20th Century Fox. Here however White is played by Glenn Tryon.But White himself is extraneous to this story which concerns two backstage plots. White's number one assistant Philip Terry falls for Martha Holiday whose mother back in the day was chorus girl in the Scandals but who married English nobility and retired. Now Holiday is trying out but lets no one know including Terry. Holiday also has Jane Greer as a rival who is pretty ruthless about getting her way.The second story concerns those lovebirds Jack Haley and Joan Davis who are both in the Scandals. They'd like to get married, but Haley promised his dear old parents that he wouldn't until his sister did. Unfortunately his sister is Margaret Hamilton and if you think the Wicked Witch intimidated the Tin Man in The Wizard Of Oz wait until you see her in this film. They even hire a professional escort for her in Fritz Feld who falls down on the job.That last one is pretty silly, but the players make it work. The best song in the score is the revived Life Is Just A Bowl Of Cherries which was introduced in the 1931 version of the Scandals on Broadway. It was introduced by Rudy Vallee and too bad they couldn't have gotten him to do it in the film. Vallee and White however came to a nasty parting of the ways and I doubt Rudy would have made himself available for this film.It's not MGM and it shows, but George White's Scandals is a decent enough film and it also features Gene Krupa and his band and Ethel Smith on her Tico Tico organ.Fans of the Wizard Of Oz might like to see Haley and Hamilton as brother and sister. No one is putting a smile on Margaret Hamilton's face.

mark.waltz This is the type of musical comedy that only works when the comic players are on screen. What is going on with the more traditional romantic plot line just isn't as interesting here. Where it is very funny (and very worth watching) is for the re-teaming of Joan Davis and Jack Haley as musical revue comics who have to deal with the fact that Haley's spinster sister (the wonderful Margaret Hamilton) does not approve of her brother being in show business and is determined to keep Davis from marrying him no matter what. Davis and Haley are perfectly matched (having worked together at 20th Century Fox in the late 1930's, and of course it is a delight to see Hamilton playing sister to her "Wizard of Oz" co-star (Haley). While she doesn't threaten to turn him into a beehive here, she does threaten to pull Davis's blonde hair out by its black roots, and tries to knock off Davis comically with a hatchet after finding out that the man Davis tried to fix her up with is a gigolo (played by that French lip popper, Fritz Feld). Hamilton, a gentle soul off screen, screeches "Who put you up to this?" with all the venom she had demonstrated as a wicked witch later known as Elphaba. The film sags when they are off screen, which identifies why it is perhaps not as well known as it would be otherwise. The other story deals with the daughter (Martha Holliday) of one of Davis's old "Scandals" cronies who wants to break into show business in spite of the fact that her father is a British nobleman. In that story-line, only Jane Greer (billed as "Bettyjane") offers any heat as a bitchy headliner whose dancing talents are obviously limited, getting acquainted with a bucket of paint as Hamilton meets her match in a sandbag.It all starts off wonderfully with a lavish production number sung to "Life is Just a Bowl of Cherries" by Joan Davis's real life daughter, Beverly Willis, who is playing Joan as a kid. The line of chorus girls goes on forever thanks to a nice mirror trick. Willis is absolutely hysterical in her bit, although Davis herself provides the voice for this character. Two comical production numbers with Haley and Davis are fun too---"Who Killed Vaudeville?" has Davis and Haley imitating various contraptions, most notably Davis sounding like a stalled automobile. Another number has the two complaining about dreaming of people like Cary Grant, John Wayne and Ginger Rogers (appearing silently in outtakes from one of their recent RKO films) while looking over at their mate to find them either covered with cold cream or snoring like the car motor Joan would later imitate. Specialties by organist Ethel Smith and Gene Krupa's band round out the musical numbers, while a montage of production numbers representing a "Scandals" performance appear to be outtakes from other RKO films. Krupa's drum playing is filled with energy. Another sweet moment comes when Davis's helium voiced maid (Rosemary Murphy) sings "Wishing", originally heard in the 1939 classic "Love Affair". While Ms. Davis would be paired by RKO in two films with Eddie Cantor, I much prefer her pairing with Haley. They seem like an ideal sitcom couple, although her later partner on "I Married Joan" was a perfect foil for her--- Jim Backus.

Dead_Mann its an average corny musical,from the mid 40s, that has many flaws, but can still be kinda fun to watch, if you're in to older movies....it has an OK cast including Joan Davis, Jack Haley, Philip Terry, Martha Holiday, Ethel smith, Margaret Hamilton, Glenn Tryon, Jane Greer,Audrey Young.......the musicals parts of the movie are OK but very corny and kinda stupid, like most musicals back then i guess, so i cant totally say i recommend this, but it wasn't totally bad i guess, if you do want to see it, good luck finding it.....